Keypoints Summary – Ranking Top Quarterbacks 2025
- Tiered ranking of all 32 starting NFL quarterbacks for 2025
- Josh Allen’s MVP talent faces weapon concerns
- Joe Burrow gets elite receivers—but are they enough?
- Breakout potential for Jordan Love, Anthony Richardson
- Big pressure on rookies Caleb Williams, Drake Maye
- Patrick Mahomes still rules, but who can challenge him?
- Justin Herbert, Jalen Hurts, and Lamar Jackson in prove-it mode
- Every QB has upside, but not every team gives them the tools
This year is already thrilling!
The minute training camp photos hit the feed, you know the takes are coming. Quarterback debates explode like popcorn. Everyone has a hot list. Everyone’s an expert. But this year? It’s different. We’re entering chaos. Fresh blood. Veteran urgency. Super Bowl or bust vibes. So yeah, ranking all 32 NFL starting quarterbacks by tier heading into the 2025 season is an out of control task—but we live for this kind of drama.
I’m not here to bore you with completion percentages. This is about electricity. Swagger. Clutch. It’s about what happens when the pocket collapses, the noise is deafening, and the season’s on the line. It’s about projecting where these quarterbacks will rank when the final whistle blows in January. You ready? Because the top quarterbacks 2025 list is not going to be polite.
Tier 1: Kings Who Might Break the League
These are the guys who will ruin your Sunday and headline every Monday morning debate. They’re the faces of franchises. Super Bowl or bust.
Josh Allen – He’s got MVP talent and alien-like ability. But where are the weapons? Buffalo’s roster is thinning. Still, Allen alone is chaos incarnate. Top three ceiling.
Patrick Mahomes – Until someone else takes his crown, he wears it. Even with half a receiving corps, he finds ways to destroy you. Smart money says he finishes No. 1 again.
Joe Burrow – He’s got the swagger, the arm, the ice in his veins. If the line holds and the defense steps up, Burrow could have a career year. Ja’Marr Chase and Higgins make him lethal.
Jalen Hurts – Philly’s offense is still stacked. Hurts has the mobility, the leadership, and the resume. But will the loss of Jason Kelce shake the foundation?
Tier 2: They’ve Got the Juice—But Questions Linger
These guys flash elite upside. Some have already made deep playoff runs. But injuries, inconsistency, or coaching changes could shift their 2025 fate.
Justin Herbert – He’s got the arm. He’s got the look. But does he have the clutch gene? New weapons help. But the AFC is ruthless.
Lamar Jackson – MVP-level magic when healthy. But it always comes down to durability. If Todd Monken fully unlocks him, Lamar could leap back into the top tier.
Trevor Lawrence – The talent is undeniable. But last year felt flat. He’ll need to prove the leap wasn’t a fluke. Pressure’s on.
Dak Prescott – Regular season rockstar. Postseason ghost. He needs to carry Dallas deeper this year or the noise gets louder.
Aaron Rodgers – The legend returns. But will he still have it? If he stays upright and the Jets’ defense holds, he could stun the league. Or fade completely.
Tier 3: Wild Cards with Superstar Potential
These QBs could skyrocket—or crash. They’re young, unpredictable, and dangerous. Bet on growth, but brace for chaos.
Jordan Love – The breakout is real. He’s got poise, mobility, and a laser for an arm. If Green Bay builds around him, Love could leap a tier by season’s end.
Anthony Richardson – Built like a tank, moves like a receiver, throws like a cannon. If he stays healthy, he might be the most exciting QB in the AFC South.
C.J. Stroud – Calm, accurate, and already looking like a ten-year vet. Houston’s offense is on the rise, and Stroud is its centerpiece.
Deshaun Watson – Once elite. Now…who knows? He has a full offseason to reset. If it clicks, watch out. If it doesn’t, it gets awkward fast.
Brock Purdy – Still not flashy. Still just winning. People doubt him because he’s not sexy. But the 49ers believe. He could crack Tier 2 with another playoff run.
Tier 4: Solid, Safe, and Maybe a Little Boring
These guys won’t ruin your season, but they won’t carry it either. You win with the roster. Not just the quarterback.
Kirk Cousins – New uniform, same result? He’ll get yards. He’ll win some games. He’ll lose in prime time. That’s the Kirk life.
Geno Smith – Nobody expected the rise. But now he has to prove it wasn’t a fluke. Seattle needs him to steady the ship.
Russell Wilson – Make-or-break time. Sean Payton has no patience. Wilson needs to start fast or sit down.
Jared Goff – Detroit’s offense is rolling. But can Goff handle January pressure? His ceiling is clear. It’s his floor that’s improved.
Tua Tagovailoa – Quick reads, fast throws, speed around him. But durability is the constant concern. Tua needs to stay upright to stay in the top half.
Tier 5: The New Guys and the Unknowns
Rookies and second-year players with potential—but nothing guaranteed. These are the mystery boxes. Some will explode. Some will bust.
Caleb Williams – He’s got the “it” factor. Pocket creativity. Deep ball swagger. But the Bears need to protect him, fast.
Drake Maye – Big arm. Pro-style mind. The Patriots finally have a potential star. But patience will be required.
Jayden Daniels – Electric with his legs. The deep ball looks good. But the Washington situation could get messy quickly.
J.J. McCarthy – Winner at Michigan. But can he produce at the pro level? The Vikings believe. Now he has to show it.
Bryce Young – Last year was brutal. He was thrown to the wolves. But the Panthers made changes. If he rebounds, he could silence doubters.
Tier 6: Just Trying to Hold the Job
These guys are starting—for now. But they’re walking a tightrope. One bad month, and it’s clipboard time.
Baker Mayfield – Still scrappy. Still loud. Tampa Bay isn’t terrible. But is Baker the guy or just a placeholder?
Sam Howell – A few flashes. A lot of growing pains. The leash will be short.
Desmond Ridder – Falcons still aren’t sold. Neither is the league.
Aidan O’Connell – Vegas wants to believe. But will the new staff trust him long term?
Zach Wilson – The last shot. If he plays, something’s gone horribly wrong in Denver. This might be it.
The rankings will shift. They always do. Someone we doubted will rise. Someone crowned too soon will fall. That’s the beauty of projecting the top quarterbacks 2025. It’s more than stats. It’s about storylines, grit, and chaos. There’s no perfect list. But this one? It’s built for what’s coming.
Let the takes fly. Let the debates heat up. And when the dust settles in January, we’ll see who really belongs in the top tier.